Stop Investing in “The Stock Market”

When most investors think about the stock market, they’re focused on direction.

Is the index up or down?
Is it near highs or pulling back?
What’s the headline narrative today?

That lens is almost entirely index-driven and market-cap weighted.

A handful of very large stocks end up doing most of the talking, and whatever they’re doing becomes the story.

That’s not wrong. It’s just limited.

The problem with thinking only in index terms is that it hides what’s happening underneath the surface.

Markets don’t move as a single unit.

Stocks move at different speeds, in different directions, and for different reasons.

Leadership rotates. Participation expands and contracts.

Entire groups can trend higher while the index goes nowhere.

When you only watch the index, you miss that dispersion.

You miss where capital is quietly flowing.

And by the time those moves become obvious in the headline averages, much of the opportunity has already passed.

When you start thinking in terms of the market of stocks, the questions change.

Instead of asking, “Is the market bullish or bearish?” you start asking things like:

• Are more stocks participating in the move?

• Where is leadership broadening or narrowing?

• Which areas are resting, and which ones are stepping up?

This lens is less about prediction and more about confirmation.

It’s about understanding whether strength is concentrated in a few names or spreading across many.

We see this play out all the time.

There are plenty of periods where the index chops sideways and the narrative turns cautious, even though a growing number of stocks are pushing higher.

Breakouts work. Breakdowns fail. New leaders emerge away from the obvious places.

From an index perspective, it can feel like nothing is happening.

From a market-of-stocks perspective, there’s plenty going on.

That’s where opportunity tends to live.

This is where process comes in.

By consistently tracking participation, leadership, and trend across different parts of the market, you don’t need to guess what comes next.

You simply respond to what’s already happening.

There will be times when concentration works and owning the index makes sense.

There will be other times when the index understates opportunity and the better bets live elsewhere.

Both can be true. The key is knowing which environment you’re in.

Don’t let the index do all the thinking for you.

The stock market gives you a headline.

The market of stocks gives you context.

When you take the time to look under the hood, you don’t need to predict outcomes or chase narratives.

You just follow participation, respect trend, and stay flexible as leadership rotates.

Anyway, that’s my two cents.

🎥 Thompson Two Cents Live

🚀 Throw it on 1.5x speed and let it rip.

👍 Give it a like. It’s the easiest way to show me some love.  

The Sunday Stalk List

If you want clean charts, clear setups, and tactical insights — this one’s for you.

It hits inboxes every Sunday so you know exactly what to keep an eye on for the week ahead.

Checkout last weeks post.

Cheers,

Larry Thompson, CMT CPA

Follow Me On Twitter (X)

Follow Me on StockTwits

Sign Up For Thompson’s Two Cents